In a federal lawsuit brought on Tuesday by Harry Belafonte against the estate of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Mr. Belafonte is seeking a declaratory judgment from the Manhattan court declaring his ownership in three documents related to Dr. King. These three documents include: an outline of a Vietnam War speech by King, notes to a speech King never got to deliver in Memphis, Tenn. and a condolence letter from President Lyndon B. Johnson to King’s wife after the civil rights leader’s 1968 assassination in Memphis.
The lawsuit claims that while preparing to auction these items for charity via Sothesby in 2008, the auction was “astonishingly” blocked. The heirs of the late Dr. King–Dexter, Bernice and Martin Luther King, III, claimed that the documents belong to the estate of Dr. King and were taken and used against the permission of the estate. Their claims against Mr. Belafonte ultimately stalled the auction and the documents are reportedly in a storage unit held by Sothesby.
What Does This Mean?:
A declaratory judgment is a legally binding court authoritative opinion ultimately telling both parties what their rights and responsibilities are, without any awards for damages or orders being entered.
Mr. Belanfonte claims that Dr. King often times gave away the notes to many of his speeches. In the case of these three documents Mr. Belafonte claims that a set of notes regarding the Vietnam speech was left at his apartment, the notes from the speech to be given in Memphis were once offered to him by Coretta Scott King and later bequeath to him upon the death of Mr. Levison (a close aide of Dr. King) and also the letter from President Johnson was offered to him by Mrs. King about a decade ago due to her admiration of his collection.
Mr. Belafonte also asserts Dr. King’s children and his estate have offered no evidence that the items were stolen or otherwise procured without permission.
How Does This Affect You?:
As an author of a body or work, whether it be a song, book or notes to speech, you own a copyright to that work which, in this case of a work established before 1978, is life plus either 70, 95 or 120 years.
Mr. Belafonte is not asserting ownership to the content of the speeches, but rather the actual tangible document upon which they are housed.
According to the New York Times, Clarence B. Jones, Dr. King’s lawyer and close friend, said the King family had every right to protect its copyright. Still, he said the heirs’ attempt to recover documents from Mr. Belafonte was “inconsistent with, and, really, a denigration of, the love and integrity that their dad had for the people who worked with him.”
It is common for many tangible forms of works of art to be sold to collectors regardless of ownership in the actual copyright of the content. If you are a budding politician, song writer or author, and you want to preserve the legacy of the tangible manner upon which your content was created, then you must be diligent in how you discard of material and also in how it is given to others or left within your estate.
As Dr. King was a man immense giving with a desire to protect the rights of all, I am certain the claims made by his estate are far from what he envisioned.
Rashida Maples, Esq. is Founder and Managing Partner of J. Maples & Associates (www.jmaplesandassociates.com). She has practiced Entertainment, Real Estate and Small Business Law for 9 years, handling both transactional and litigation matters. Her clients include R&B Artists Bilal and Olivia, NFL Superstar Ray Lewis, Fashion Powerhouse Harlem’s Fashion Row and Hirschfeld Properties, LLC.
LIKE HelloBeautiful On Facebook!
Also On HelloBeautiful:
Celebs Tweet Their Thoughts About #JusticeForSandraBland
1. Jesse Williams
#SandraBland's treatment while attempting to travel freely on HER public roadways has been acknowledged as unlawful. She is already dead.
2. Taraji P. Henson
"SAY HER NAME #SandraBland"
3. Ava DuVernay
"'Why are you arresting me?' Because you know your rights. Because I can. Because no one'll believe you. #SandraBland"
4. Kim Kardashian
#WhatHappenedToSandraBland We need answers!!!! This is NOT ok! This is all shady! They need to own up to this & tell the truth!
5. Jussie Smollet
"A loss 4 words. #SandraBlandMatters #BlackLivesMatter 👈🏿tell me this should change once the nation shows that we do. "
6. Snoop Dogg
🙏🌹. Sandra. Rip. 🌹🌹
7. K. Michelle
R.I.P to this queen. This could've been any of us. My prayers go out to her family. #sandrabland https://instagram.com/p/5fvlO_AhCf/
8. Gabrielle Union
SAY HER NAME!!! #SandraBland #SandraBland #SandraBland #SayHerName
"We must get to the cause of #sandrabland death because this CANNOT happen again #deathorfreedom"
10. David Banner
"When will we fight back. A man's duty on earth is to protect women and children. Where are the gangsters? Preachers? We need you. Please."
11. Nicki Minaj
"Rest In Peace #SandraBland"
12. Talib Kweli
"We the people ask @LorettaLynch to investigate #SandraBland #KimberleeRandleKing RETWEET "
Signs. Signs. Signs all around us. The Message is Here. #SandraBland
14. Missy Elliot
"When I look at the #SandraBland traffic video it brings so many emotions😳😢😡😡😤!"
15. Jessie J
"God bless your soul Sandra | #sandrabland | Change needs to come |Justice needs to be served | Heart… https://instagram.com/p/5fV79mQ0aw/ "
16. Jackee Harry
"It's time y'all, it's time.." #SandraBland #BlackLivesMatter
"In memory of #SandraBland these things don't make no kinda sense "
18. Holly Robinson Peete
I really don't look forward to having ANOTHER difficult conversation w my kids tonight...but here we go again😧💔 #SandraBland #SayHerName 😢
19. Jeffrey White
Sadly, doesn't matter by whose hand she died. Unjustified arrested set the outcome in motion. The state murdered her. #JusticeForSandraBland
Sandra could have been your mother, sister, aunt, friend or if she wasn't killed the community outreach advisor A&M. #SandraBland
21. Joan Smalls
"My heart is broken. Sending my deepest condolence to her family and friends. May you find Strength, Peace and Justice. When will this stop? #EqualityForAll #RIP #Why #SayHerName
22. Gladys Knight
Sandra Bland.... #SayHerName #SandraBland
23. Cara Delevigne
Things need to change NOW #SANDRABLAND #Justice #Equality
24. Meek Mill
"Rip to that young lady that lost her life about a traffic stop! 🙏 ima make sure I pray for her and her family! 🙏😄😄😄"