Hellobeautiful Featured Video
Beyonce 'The Formation World Tour' - New York City

Source: Larry Busacca/PW / Getty

A federal judge recently threw out a lawsuit filed against Beyoncé by filmmaker Matthew Fulks.  

According to The Hollywood Reporter, Fulks claimed that the Lemonade star plagiarized nine visuals from his short film Palinoia, including the the low-light shots of a “parking garage” and shots of “graffiti on walls.” 

However in court, U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff stated that Beyonce´didn’t lift Fulks’ images, but didn’t go into details as to how he got that conclusion. 

Upon full consideration of the parties’ briefs and oral arguments, the Court grants defendants’ motion. A memorandum explaining the reasons for this ruling will issue in due course, at which time final judgment will be entered,” he wrote. 

As HELLO BEAUTIFUL previously reported, Fulks claimed that after being contacted with the opportunity to work with Columbia artists MS MR, a link to his short film was sent to Columbia Records’ Bryan Younce. In July 2015, Younce sent Fulks a note inviting him to submit a video treatment for consideration by Columbia. Later that year, filming began for Lemonade and Fulks wasn’t including in that process.

And while looking at the screen stills side by side they are similar, Queen Bey was very clear that she didn’t copy anyone: “Lemonade portrays “an African-American woman who progresses through stages of suspicion, denial, anger and, ultimately, reconciliation in her relationship.” On the other hand, she says Palinoia is about a “white man who is distressed in the wake of a failed relationship,” she said in court docs in July.

Boy bye, we guess.


Beyoncé Calls Out White Man For Saying She Stole ‘Lemonade’ Visuals

Happy Birthday, Beyoncé! Singer Spends 35th With First Family

Chance The Rapper Loses It Over Beyoncé, Plus More Moments You Didn’t See At The 2016 VMAs

For 2024’s iteration of MadameNoire and HelloBeautiful’s annual series Women to Know, we knew we wanted to celebrate the people who help make the joys of film and television possible. To create art is to create magic. This year, we spotlight Hollywood Executive’s changing the face of cinema.